U.S. Scott #C23 #C23

U.S. First Day Cover Cachet Display Catalog:
U.S. Scott #C23 FDC Cachet List and Display in Planty Order:
Eagle Holding Shield, 20th Anniversary of the Air Mail Service

Part of the U.S. First Day Cover Cachet Display Catalog
by Douglas H. Henkle, AFDCS LM #137, henkle@pobox.com

(last updated .03-24-2024)

FDC Publishing Co. Planty Catalog Numbers

Menu Pages: Search this site
Main Menu -- Wisconsin Cachetmakers -- All Cachetmakers -- Catalog Numbers -- Bibliographies -- Site Map -- What's New

Previous: Planty #C21-22 Cachet List -- Next: Planty #C24 Cachet List -- All U.S. Scott # Cachet Lists
Cachet Display Catalog: FDC Cachetmakers Index

      This page lists all First Day Cover (FDC) Cachets for U.S. Scott #C23 in Planty Catalog Number Order.

      What's New on this page

      U.S. Scott #C23 was issued on 5-14-1938 at Dayton, OH and St. Petersburg, FL - (6¢)
      Eagle Holding Shield, 20th Anniversary of the Air Mail Service, 1918-1938
      Minkus A23 [2003 Krause-Minkus Catalog, p. 405]
Dayton, OH -- Home of the Wright Brothers
St. Petersburg, FL -- First Passenger Service
Washington, DC -- 2nd day cancel, 5-15-1938

FDC Publishing Co. Planty Catalog Numbers

   U.S. Scott #C23-nn = each cachet's Planty Catalog number.
   U.S. Scott #C23-nn = e.g. https://www.folklib.net/fdc/bibliog/planty-c23.shtml#C23-GP1 - each cachet on this page can be linked to individually by using "#" and its shown Planty Catalog Number.
   XIII:nn = the page number(s) this cachet is documented in Mellone's Planty Photo Encyclopedia of Cacheted First Day Covers, 2001, Volume XIII, 2nd ed.
        [Planty's Photo Encyclopedia of Cacheted F.D.C.s, 1984, Volume X, 1st ed. cannot be indexed because it has no 1,2,3... sequential page numbers.]
   (was ...) = the Cachetmaker identification in the 1st edition was unknown or incorrect.
   [#nnn, ...] = references to articles in the AFDCS (American First Day Cover Society's) journal, FIRST DAYS.
   Cachetmaker's name link = click on the name for possible birth/death dates, website links and/or FIRST DAYS article references for that Cachetmaker.
   ACE #, RCD # = only the Cachetmaker's Art Cover Exchange and Registered Cachet Director membership numbers are listed here. Click on their name for their possible other AFDCS, ANCS or USCS membership numbers that I know about.

      Wanted: a 300 bpi / 600 pixel wide (or greater) .jpg scan of any unlisted cachet (ALSO any cachet marked ***)
Email it to: henkle@pobox.com
Subject for this page: Doug Henkle unlisted Scott #C23 cachet
      (an email with any other subject or with any other graphical format will be ignored IF it has an attachment)

      Scan sources, if other than off the Web: {A} = from my own collection, (DLD) = from David L. DuBois .

(GP) General Purpose
(PC) Post Cards
(A) More Recent Add-Ons
(FC-NIP) First Cachets, all Not in Planty
  1. U.S. Scott #C23-1a - Dr. Harry C. Ioor, RCD #107 -- XIII:80 -- {A} / {A}
    U.S. Scott #C23-1a - Dr. Harry C. Ioor U.S. Scott #C23-1a - Dr. Harry C. Ioor
  2. U.S. Scott #C23-1b - Dr. Harry C. Ioor, RCD #107 -- XIII:80 --- (eBay)
    U.S. Scott #C23-1b - Dr. Harry C. Ioor U.S. Scott #C23-1b - Dr. Harry C. Ioor
  3. U.S. Scott #C23-1c-NIP - Dr. Harry C. Ioor, RCD #107 -- XIII:80 --- (eBay)
          "Anniversary" misspelled "Annivesary"
    U.S. Scott #C23-1c - Dr. Harry C. Ioor U.S. Scott #C23-1c - Dr. Harry C. Ioor U.S. Scott #C23-1c - Dr. Harry C. Ioor U.S. Scott #C23-1c - Dr. Harry C. Ioor
  4. U.S. Scott #C23-2 - unknown -- XIII:80 -- (eBay)
    U.S. Scott #C23-2 - unknown
  5. U.S. Scott #C23-3 - Albert C. Roessler (Charles) -- XIII:80 -- (eBay)
    U.S. Scott #C23-3 - Albert C. Roessler (Charles)
  6. U.S. Scott #C23-3a - Albert C. Roessler (Charles) -- XIII:80 -- (eBay)
    U.S. Scott #C23-3a - Albert C. Roessler (Charles)
  7. U.S. Scott #C23-4 - Pilgrim -- XIII:80 -- (eBay)
    U.S. Scott #C23-4 - Pilgrim
  8. U.S. Scott #C23-5 - Waterbury, CT National Air Mail Week -- XIII:80-81
  9. U.S. Scott #C23-6 - Pocatello, ID National Air Mail Week -- XIII:81
  10. U.S. Scott #C23-7a - 1st R.D. Barry -- XIII:81
  11. U.S. Scott #C23-7b - 1st R.D. Barry -- XIII:81
  12. U.S. Scott #C23-8 - unknown -- XIII:81
  13. U.S. Scott #C23-9a - unknown -- XIII:81-82 -- (eBay)
    U.S. Scott #C23-9a - unknown U.S. Scott #C23-9a - unknown
  14. U.S. Scott #C23-9a.1 - unknown -- XIII:81-82
  15. U.S. Scott #C23-9b - unknown -- XIII:81-82

  16. U.S. Scott #C23-10 - 1st Commercial Travelers Mutual Accident Association, Utica, NY -- XIII:82
  17. U.S. Scott #C23-11 - Chambersburg Stamp Club -- XIII:82
  18. U.S. Scott #C23-12 - Munprint (Edward A. Munn Jr.) -- XIII:82 --- (eBay)
    U.S. Scott #C23-12 - Munprint (Edward A. Munn Jr.)
  19. U.S. Scott #C23-13 - unknown -- XIII:82 --- (eBay)
    U.S. Scott #C23-13 - unknown U.S. Scott #C23-13 - unknown
  20. U.S. Scott #C23-13a - unknown -- XIII:82
  21. U.S. Scott #C23-13b - unknown -- XIII:82
  22. U.S. Scott #C23-14 - F.R. Ferryman -- XIII:82 --- (eBay)
    U.S. Scott #C23-14 - F.R. Ferryman U.S. Scott #C23-14 - F.R. Ferryman
    This is on a different type of paper but I don't know how to describe it correctly, pebbled?.
    U.S. Scott #C23-14 - F.R. Ferryman U.S. Scott #C23-14 - F.R. Ferryman
  23. U.S. Scott #C23-15a - Washington Stamp Exchange (WSE) -- XIII:82-83 -- (eBay)
    U.S. Scott #C23-15a - Washington Stamp Exchange (WSE)
  24. U.S. Scott #C23-15b - Washington Stamp Exchange (WSE) -- XIII:82-83 -- (eBay) / (eBay) / (eBay)
    U.S. Scott #C23-15b - Washington Stamp Exchange (WSE) U.S. Scott #C23-15b - Washington Stamp Exchange (WSE) U.S. Scott #C23-15b - Washington Stamp Exchange (WSE)
    U.S. Scott #C23-15b - Washington Stamp Exchange (WSE) U.S. Scott #C23-15b - Washington Stamp Exchange (WSE)
  25. U.S. Scott #C23-16a - Linprint -- XIII:83 -- {A} / (eBay)
    U.S. Scott #C23-16a - Linprint U.S. Scott #C23-16a - Linprint
  26. U.S. Scott #C23-16b - Linprint -- XIII:83
  27. U.S. Scott #C23-17 - W.M. Grandy (Winfred Milton), RCD #130 -- XIII:83-84 -- (eBay) / (eBay)
    U.S. Scott #C23-17 - W.M. Grandy (Winfred Milton) U.S. Scott #C23-17 - W.M. Grandy (Winfred Milton) U.S. Scott #C23-17 - W.M. Grandy (Winfred Milton) U.S. Scott #C23-17 - W.M. Grandy (Winfred Milton) U.S. Scott #C23-17 - W.M. Grandy (Winfred Milton)
  28. U.S. Scott #C23-17.1 - W.M. Grandy (Winfred Milton), RCD #130 -- XIII:83-84
  29. U.S. Scott #C23-17a - W.M. Grandy (Winfred Milton), RCD #130 -- XIII:83-84
  30. U.S. Scott #C23-17b - W.M. Grandy (Winfred Milton), RCD #130 -- XIII:83-84
  31. U.S. Scott #C23-17c - W.M. Grandy (Winfred Milton), RCD #130 -- XIII:83-84
  32. U.S. Scott #C23-18 - American Air Mail Society (AAMS) -- XIII:84 --- (eBay)
    U.S. Scott #C23-18 - American Air Mail Society (AAMS)
  33. U.S. Scott #C23-18a - American Air Mail Society (AAMS) -- XIII:84
  34. U.S. Scott #C23-19 - Fidelity Stamp Co. -- XIII:84 -- (eBay)
    U.S. Scott #C23-19 - Fidelity Stamp Co. U.S. Scott #C23-19 - Fidelity Stamp Co.
  35. U.S. Scott #C23-19a - Fidelity Stamp Co. -- XIII:84 -- (eBay)
    U.S. Scott #C23-19a - Fidelity Stamp Co. U.S. Scott #C23-19a - Fidelity Stamp Co.
  36. U.S. Scott #C23-19b - Fidelity Stamp Co. -- XIII:84 -- (eBay)
    U.S. Scott #C23-19b - Fidelity Stamp Co.
  37. U.S. Scott #C23-19c - Fidelity Stamp Co. -- XIII:84

  38. U.S. Scott #C23-20 - Fairway -- XIII:84 --- (eBay)
    U.S. Scott #C23-20 - Fairway U.S. Scott #C23-20 - Fairway
  39. U.S. Scott #C23-21 - Glen L. Evans -- XIII:84-85 -- (StampAuctionNetwork)
    U.S. Scott #C23-21 - Glen L. Evans
  40. U.S. Scott #C23-22 - House of Farnam -- XIII:85 -- (eBay)
    U.S. Scott #C23-22 - House of Farnam
  41. U.S. Scott #C23-22a - House of Farnam -- XIII:85 -- (eBay)
    U.S. Scott #C23-22a - House of Farnam U.S. Scott #C23-22a - House of Farnam
  42. U.S. Scott #C23-23a - Torkel Gundel -- XIII:85 --- (eBay)
    U.S. Scott #C23-23a - Torkel Gundel
  43. U.S. Scott #C23-23b - Torkel Gundel -- XIII:85 -- (eBay)
    U.S. Scott #C23-23b - Torkel Gundel U.S. Scott #C23-23b - Torkel Gundel
  44. U.S. Scott #C23-23c - Torkel Gundel -- XIII:85
  45. U.S. Scott #C23-24 - 1st AAMS, American Air Mail Society, Tony Jannus Chapter (red) (NOT Janus) -- XIII:85 -- (eBay)
    U.S. Scott #C23-24 - 1st AAMS, American Air Mail Society, Tony Jannus Chapter
  46. U.S. Scott #C23-24a - 1st AAMS, American Air Mail Society, Tony Jannus Chapter (dark nlue) (NOT Janus) -- XIII:85 -- (eBay)
    U.S. Scott #C23-24a - 1st AAMS, American Air Mail Society, Tony Jannus Chapter
  47. U.S. Scott #C23-24b - 1st AAMS, American Air Mail Society, Tony Jannus Chapter (blue-violet) (NOT Janus) -- XIII:85 -- {A}
    U.S. Scott #C23-24b - 1st AAMS, American Air Mail Society, Tony Jannus Chapter U.S. Scott #C23-24b - 1st AAMS, American Air Mail Society, Tony Jannus Chapter
  48. U.S. Scott #C23-25 - Michael Sanders, RCD #156 -- XIII:85-86
  49. U.S. Scott #C23-25a - Michael Sanders, RCD #156 -- XIII:85-86
  50. U.S. Scott #C23-26 - Risko Art Studio (Harry Charles Risko), RCD #110 -- XIII:86 --- (eBay) / (DLD) / (DLD) / (DLD)
          2 lines text, with various design variations
    U.S. Scott #C23-26 - Risko Art Studio (Harry Charles Risko) U.S. Scott #C23-26 - Harry Charles Risko U.S. Scott #C23-26 - Harry Charles Risko U.S. Scott #C23-26 - Harry Charles Risko
  51. U.S. Scott #C23-26a-NIP - Risko Art Studio (Harry Charles Risko), RCD #110 -- XIII:86 --- (DLD)
          3 lines text
    U.S. Scott #C23-26a-NIP - Harry Charles Risko
  52. U.S. Scott #C23-27 - Egon Bernet -- XIII:86
  53. U.S. Scott #C23-27a - Egon Bernet -- XIII:86
  54. U.S. Scott #C23-27b - Egon Bernet -- XIII:86
  55. U.S. Scott #C23-28a - William T. Raley (W.T.) -- XIII:86 --- (eBay)
    U.S. Scott #C23-27a - William T. Raley (W.T.)
  56. U.S. Scott #C23-28b - William T. Raley (W.T.) -- XIII:86 --- (eBay)
    U.S. Scott #C23-27b - William T. Raley (W.T.) U.S. Scott #C23-27b - William T. Raley (W.T.) U.S. Scott #C23-27b - William T. Raley (W.T.)
  57. U.S. Scott #C23-29 - J.C. Sidenius (John / Jack) -- XIII:86 -- (eBay)
    U.S. Scott #C23-29 - J.C. Sidenius (John / Jack) U.S. Scott #C23-29 - J.C. Sidenius (John / Jack)
  58. U.S. Scott #C23-29a - J.C. Sidenius (John / Jack) -- XIII:86
  59. U.S. Scott #C23-29b - J.C. Sidenius (John / Jack) -- XIII:86

  60. U.S. Scott #C23-30 - F.R. Rice (Frederick Roger) -- XIII:87 --- (eBay)
    U.S. Scott #C23-30 - F.R. Rice (Frederick Roger) U.S. Scott #C23-30 - F.R. Rice (Frederick Roger)
  61. U.S. Scott #C23-30a - F.R. Rice (Frederick Roger) -- XIII:87 --- (eBay)
    U.S. Scott #C23-30a - F.R. Rice (Frederick Roger) U.S. Scott #C23-30a - F.R. Rice (Frederick Roger)
  62. U.S. Scott #C23-31 - Fred Chambers -- XIII:87 --- (eBay)
          With a Luckey, OH unofficial cancel on a cachet made specifically for this city. This is the only cataloged cachet Fred Chambers made for #C23.
    U.S. Scott #C23-31 - Fred Chambers
  63. U.S. Scott #C23-32 - Beverly Hills (Red & blue on white envelope) -- XIII:87 --- (eBay)
    U.S. Scott #C23-32 - Beverly Hills
  64. U.S. Scott #C23-32.1 - Beverly Hills (Blue & orange on white envelope) -- XIII:87 --- (eBay)
    U.S. Scott #C23-32.1 - Beverly Hills
  65. U.S. Scott #C23-32.2 - Beverly Hills (Blue & red on light yellow envelope) -- XIII:87
  66. U.S. Scott #C23-32.3 - Beverly Hills (Blue & red on yellow envelope) -- XIII:87
  67. U.S. Scott #C23-32.4 - Beverly Hills (Blue & red on white envelope) -- XIII:87
  68. U.S. Scott #C23-32.5 - Beverly Hills (Blue & red on grey envelope) -- XIII:87
  69. U.S. Scott #C23-32.6 - Beverly Hills (Blue & yellow on grey envelope) -- XIII:87
  70. U.S. Scott #C23-32.7 - Beverly Hills (Blue & red on dark yellow envelope) -- XIII:87
  71. U.S. Scott #C23-32.8 - Beverly Hills (Blue & yellow on peach envelope) -- XIII:87
  72. U.S. Scott #C23-32.9 - Beverly Hills (Blue & red on peach envelope) -- XIII:87 --- (eBay)
    U.S. Scott #C23-32.9 - Beverly Hills
  73. U.S. Scott #C23-32.10 - Beverly Hills (Blue & yellow on deep pink envelope) -- XIII:87 --- (eBay)
    U.S. Scott #C23-32.10 - Beverly Hills
  74. U.S. Scott #C23-32.11 - Beverly Hills (Blue & red on light green envelope) -- XIII:87
  75. U.S. Scott #C23-32.12 - Beverly Hills (Blue & yellow on light green envelope) -- XIII:87
  76. U.S. Scott #C23-32a - Beverly Hills (Blue & yellow on white envelope) -- XIII:87
  77. U.S. Scott #C23-32b - Beverly Hills (Blue & yellow on white envelope) -- XIII:87
  78. U.S. Scott #C23-33 - Pavois (Stebbin) (SM Co.) -- XIII:88 --- (eBay)
    U.S. Scott #C23-33 - Pavois (Stebbin) (SM Co.)
  79. U.S. Scott #C23-33a - Pavois (Stebbin) (SM Co.) -- XIII:88 --- (eBay)
    U.S. Scott #C23-33a - Pavois (Stebbin) (SM Co.) U.S. Scott #C23-33a - Pavois (Stebbin) (SM Co.) U.S. Scott #C23-33a - Pavois (Stebbin) (SM Co.) U.S. Scott #C23-33a - Pavois (Stebbin) (SM Co.)
  80. U.S. Scott #C23-33b - Pavois (Stebbin) (SM Co.) -- XIII:88 --- (eBay)
    U.S. Scott #C23-33b - Pavois (Stebbin) (SM Co.)
  81. U.S. Scott #C23-34 - Pavois (Stebbin) (SM Co.) -- XIII:88 --- (eBay)
          design used again for #C25-20
    U.S. Scott #C23-34 - Pavois (Stebbin) (SM Co.) U.S. Scott #C23-34 - Pavois (Stebbin) (SM Co.) U.S. Scott #C23-34 - Pavois (Stebbin) (SM Co.)
  82. U.S. Scott #C23-34a - Pavois (Stebbin) (SM Co.) -- XIII:88
  83. U.S. Scott #C23-34b - Pavois (Stebbin) (SM Co.) -- XIII:88
    U.S. Scott #C23-34b - Pavois (Stebbin) (SM Co.)
  84. U.S. Scott #C23-35 - Henry Grimsland (blue) -- XIII:88 -- {A} / (eBay) / (eBay)
    U.S. Scott #C23-35 - Henry Grimsland U.S. Scott #C23-35 - Henry Grimsland U.S. Scott #C23-35 - Henry Grimsland
  85. U.S. Scott #C23-35a-NIP - Henry Grimsland (blue and red) -- XIII:88 -- (eBay)
    U.S. Scott #C23-35a-NIP - Henry Grimsland
  86. U.S. Scott #C23-36a - Louis G. Nix (Gregor) @ -- XIII:88-89
  87. U.S. Scott #C23-36b, (4 lines) - Louis G. Nix (Gregor) @ -- XIII:88-89
  88. U.S. Scott #C23-36b.1-NIP, (3 lines, no date) - Louis G. Nix (Gregor) @ -- XIII:88-89 --- (eBay)
    U.S. Scott #C23-36b-1 - Louis G. Nix (Gregor)
  89. U.S. Scott #C23-36c - Louis G. Nix (Gregor) @ -- XIII:88-89 --- (eBay)
    U.S. Scott #C23-36c - Louis G. Nix (Gregor) U.S. Scott #C23-36c - Louis G. Nix (Gregor)
  90. U.S. Scott #C23-37 - unknown -- XIII:89 --- (eBay)
    U.S. Scott #C23-37 - unknown U.S. Scott #C23-37 - unknown
  91. U.S. Scott #C23-38a - William S. Espenshade -- XIII:89-90 --- (eBay ***Dayton) / (eBay Saint Petersburg)
    U.S. Scott #C23-38a - William S. Espenshade U.S. Scott #C23-38a - William S. Espenshade
  92. U.S. Scott #C23-38a.1 - William S. Espenshade -- XIII:89-90 --- (eBay) / (eBay)
    U.S. Scott #C23-38a.1 - William S. Espenshade U.S. Scott #C23-38a.1 - William S. Espenshade
  93. U.S. Scott #C23-38b - William S. Espenshade -- XIII:89-90
  94. U.S. Scott #C23-38b.1 - William S. Espenshade -- XIII:89-90
  95. U.S. Scott #C23-38b.2 - William S. Espenshade -- XIII:89-90
  96. U.S. Scott #C23-38b.3 - William S. Espenshade -- XIII:89-90
  97. U.S. Scott #C23-38c - William S. Espenshade -- XIII:89-90
  98. U.S. Scott #C23-38c.1 - William S. Espenshade -- XIII:89-90
  99. U.S. Scott #C23-39 - La Grange Chamber of Commerce National Air Mail Week -- XIII:90

  100. U.S. Scott #C23-40a - W.G. Crosby (Walter Garfield), RCD #96 -- XIII:90
  101. U.S. Scott #C23-40b - W.G. Crosby (Walter Garfield), RCD #96 -- XIII:90
  102. U.S. Scott #C23-41a - W.G. Crosby (Walter Garfield), RCD #96 -- XIII:90-91 --- (eBay)
    U.S. Scott #C23-41a - W.G. Crosby (Walter Garfield)
  103. U.S. Scott #C23-41b - W.G. Crosby (Walter Garfield), RCD #96 -- XIII:90-91
  104. U.S. Scott #C23-41c - W.G. Crosby (Walter Garfield), RCD #96 -- XIII:90-91 --- (eBay)
    U.S. Scott #C23-41c - W.G. Crosby (Walter Garfield)
  105. U.S. Scott #C23-42 - W.G. Crosby (Walter Garfield), RCD #96 -- XIII:91
  106. U.S. Scott #C23-43 - W.G. Crosby (Walter Garfield), RCD #96 -- XIII:91
  107. U.S. Scott #C23-43a - W.G. Crosby (Walter Garfield), RCD #96 -- XIII:91
  108. U.S. Scott #C23-43b - W.G. Crosby (Walter Garfield), RCD #96 -- XIII:91 --- (eBay)
    U.S. Scott #C23-43b - W.G. Crosby (Walter Garfield)</a>
  109. U.S. Scott #C23-44 - W.G. Crosby (Walter Garfield), RCD #96 -- XIII:91 --- (eBay)
    U.S. Scott #C23-44 - W.G. Crosby (Walter Garfield) U.S. Scott #C23-44 - W.G. Crosby (Walter Garfield)
  110. U.S. Scott #C23-45 - W.G. Crosby (Walter Garfield), RCD #96 -- XIII:91 --- (eBay)
    U.S. Scott #C23-45 - W.G. Crosby (Walter Garfield) U.S. Scott #C23-45 - W.G. Crosby (Walter Garfield)
  111. U.S. Scott #C23-46 - D.J. Kapner (Donald Joseph) -- XIII:91 --- (eBay)
    U.S. Scott #C23-46 - D.J. Kapner (Donald Joseph) U.S. Scott #C23-46 - D.J. Kapner (Donald Joseph)
  112. U.S. Scott #C23-47 - unknown -- XIII:91-92 --- (eBay)
    U.S. Scott #C23-47 - unknown U.S. Scott #C23-47 - unknown U.S. Scott #C23-47a - unknown
  113. U.S. Scott #C23-47a - unknown -- XIII:92 --- (eBay)
    U.S. Scott #C23-47a - unknown U.S. Scott #C23-47a - unknown
  114. U.S. Scott #C23-48 - Pavey Envelope & Tag Co. (was Plimpton) -- XIII:92 -- {A} /(eBay) /(eBay) /(eBay)
    U.S. Scott #C23-48 - Pavey Envelope & Tag Co. U.S. Scott #C23-48 - Pavey Envelope & Tag Co. U.S. Scott #C23-48 - Pavey Envelope & Tag Co. U.S. Scott #C23-48 - Pavey Envelope & Tag Co. U.S. Scott #C23-48 - Pavey Envelope & Tag Co.
  115. U.S. Scott #C23-49 - Ludwig W. Staehle, RCD #206 -- XIII:92 --- (eBay)
    U.S. Scott #C23-49 - Ludwig W. Staehle U.S. Scott #C23-49 - Ludwig W. Staehle

  116. U.S. Scott #C23-50 - Ludwig W. Staehle, RCD #206 -- XIII:92 --- (eBay)
    U.S. Scott #C23-50 - Ludwig W. Staehle U.S. Scott #C23-50 - Ludwig W. Staehle U.S. Scott #C23-50 - Ludwig W. Staehle
  117. U.S. Scott #C23-51 - unknown -- XIII:92 --- (eBay)
    U.S. Scott #C23-51 - unknown U.S. Scott #C23-51 - unknown
  118. U.S. Scott #C23-51a - unknown -- XIII:92
  119. U.S. Scott #C23-52 - unknown -- XIII:92 --- (eBay)
    U.S. Scott #C23-52 - unknown U.S. Scott #C23-37a-NIP - unknown U.S. Scott #C23-37a-NIP - unknown
  120. U.S. Scott #C23-53 - unknown -- XIII:92-93 -- {A}
    U.S. Scott #C23-53 - unknown
  121. U.S. Scott #C23-53a - unknown -- XIII:92-93
  122. U.S. Scott #C23-54 - unknown on a Carl M. Becken envelope -- XIII:93 --- (eBay)
    U.S. Scott #C23-54 - unknown on a Carl M. Becken envelope U.S. Scott #C23-54 - unknown on a Carl M. Becken envelope
  123. U.S. Scott #C23-54a - unknown on a Carl M. Becken envelope --- (eBay)
    U.S. Scott #C23-54a - unknown on a Carl M. Becken envelope U.S. Scott #C23-54a - unknown on a Carl M. Becken envelope
  124. U.S. Scott #C23-55 - Macos (John A. Mayne (Alden)) -- XIII:93 --- (eBay)
    U.S. Scott #C23-55 - Macos (John A. Mayne (Alden))
  125. U.S. Scott #C23-55a - Macos (John A. Mayne (Alden)) -- XIII:93 --- (eBay ***)
    U.S. Scott #C23-55a - Macos (John A. Mayne (Alden))
  126. U.S. Scott #C23-55b - Macos (John A. Mayne (Alden)) -- XIII:93 --- (eBay)
    U.S. Scott #C23-55b - Macos (John A. Mayne (Alden))
  127. U.S. Scott #C23-56 - State of Connecticut National Air Mail Week -- XIII:93
          with Norwalk, CT imprint and Dayton, OH cancel, other cancels?
  128. U.S. Scott #C23-56a - State of Connecticut National Air Mail Week -- XIII:93
          with Windsor, CT imprint and cancel, other cancels?
  129. U.S. Scott #C23-56b - State of Connecticut National Air Mail Week -- XIII:93 --- (eBay)
          2 lines at top without city imprint
    U.S. Scott #C23-56b - State of Connecticut National Air Mail Week U.S. Scott #C23-56b - State of Connecticut National Air Mail Week
  130. U.S. Scott #C23-56c-NIP - State of Connecticut National Air Mail Week -- XIII:93 --- (eBay)
          with Derby, CT imprint
    U.S. Scott #C23-56c-NIP - State of Connecticut National Air Mail Week U.S. Scott #C23-56c-NIP - State of Connecticut National Air Mail Week
  131. U.S. Scott #C23-56d-NIP - State of Connecticut National Air Mail Week -- XIII:93 --- (eBay)
          with Meriden, CT imprint (between New Haven and Hartford)
    U.S. Scott #C23-56d-NIP - State of Connecticut National Air Mail Week
  132. U.S. Scott #C23-56e-NIP - State of Connecticut National Air Mail Week -- XIII:93
          with New London, CT imprint (east of New Haven)
  133. U.S. Scott #C23-56f-NIP - State of Connecticut National Air Mail Week -- XIII:93
          with Newington, CT imprint (suburb of Hartford)
  134. U.S. Scott #C23-56g-NIP, etc. - State of Connecticut National Air Mail Week -- XIII:93
          other city imprints may exist
  135. U.S. Scott #C23-56z-NIP - State of Connecticut National Air Mail Week -- XIII:93 --- (eBay)
          with no cachet but the same airmail envelope
    U.S. Scott #C23-56z-NIP - State of Connecticut National Air Mail Week U.S. Scott #C23-56z-NIP - State of Connecticut National Air Mail Week
  136. U.S. Scott #C23-57 - Michael Sanders, RCD #156 -- XIII:94 --- (eBay)
    U.S. Scott #C23-57 - Michael Sanders U.S. Scott #C23-57 - Michael Sanders U.S. Scott #C23-57 - Michael Sanders
  137. U.S. Scott #C23-58 - Oswald A. Ludwig -- XIII:94
  138. U.S. Scott #C23-58a - Oswald A. Ludwig -- XIII:94 --- (eBay)
    U.S. Scott #C23-58a - Oswald A. Ludwig U.S. Scott #C23-58a - Oswald A. Ludwig U.S. Scott #C23-58a - Oswald A. Ludwig
  139. U.S. Scott #C23-59 - Max Casper -- XIII:94 --- (eBay)
    U.S. Scott #C23-59 - Max Casper
  140. U.S. Scott #C23-59a - Max Casper -- XIII:94

  141. U.S. Scott #C23-60 - unknown -- XIII:94
  142. U.S. Scott #C23-61 - Joseph F. Bronesky, RCD #75 -- XIII:94 --- (eBay ***)
    U.S. Scott #C23-61 - Joseph F. Bronesky
  143. U.S. Scott #C23-61a - Joseph F. Bronesky, RCD #75 -- XIII:94 --- (eBay)
    U.S. Scott #C23-61a-NIP - Joseph F. Bronesky -
  144. U.S. Scott #C23-62 - Myron F. McCamley, RCD #51 -- XIII:94
  145. U.S. Scott #C23-63 - Oak Park, IL National Air Mail Week -- XIII:95
  146. U.S. Scott #C23-64 - Sponsored by U.S. Post Office Department (was unknown) -- XIII:95
  147. U.S. Scott #C23-65 - unknown -- XIII:95
  148. U.S. Scott #C23-66 - Washington Service -- XIII:95 -- {A}
    U.S. Scott #C23-66 - Washington Service
  149. U.S. Scott #C23-67 - William Galt Keyworth @ -- XIII:95 --- (eBay)
    U.S. Scott #C23-67 - William Galt Keyworth
  150. U.S. Scott #C23-68 - Nebraska National Air Mail Week -- XIII:95 --- (eBay)
    U.S. Scott #C23-68 - Nebraska National Air Mail Week
  151. U.S. Scott #C23-69 - Tri-City Stamp Club -- XIII:95

  152. U.S. Scott #C23-70a - 1st George R.M. Ewing -- XIII:96
          (was 2nd ed. A.E. Owen (Arthur Edmund)) (was 1st ed. unknown)
  153. U.S. Scott #C23-70b - A.E. Owen (Arthur Edmund)) (was unknown) -- XIII:96
  154. U.S. Scott #C23-70c - A.E. Owen (Arthur Edmund)) (was unknown) -- XIII:96
  155. U.S. Scott #C23-71 - unknown -- XIII:96
  156. U.S. Scott #C23-72 - 1st The Reliable Fire Insurance Company -- XIII:96
  157. U.S. Scott #C23-73 - Imperial -- XIII:97
  158. U.S. Scott #C23-74 - unknown -- XIII:97
  159. U.S. Scott #C23-75 - Steep Falls, ME National Air Mail Week -- XIII:97
  160. U.S. Scott #C23-76 - unknown -- XIII:97
  161. U.S. Scott #C23-77 - unknown -- XIII:97
  162. U.S. Scott #C23-78 - David R. Annis, RCD #144, "Signed RCD 194" 144 -- XIII:97
  163. U.S. Scott #C23-78a - David R. Annis, RCD #144, "Signed RCD 194" 144 -- XIII:97 -- {A}
    U.S. Scott #C23-78a - David R. Annis
  164. U.S. Scott #C23-79 - unknown violet rubberstamp honoring Tony Jannus (NOT Janus) -- XIII:97
  165. U.S. Scott #C23-79a - unknown violet rubberstamp honoring Tony Jannus (NOT Janus) -- XIII:97 --- (eBay) / (eBay) / (eBay ***)
          on 3 types of airmail envelopes
    U.S. Scott #C23-79a - unknown violet rubbeerstamp honoring Tony Jannus U.S. Scott #C23-79a - unknown violet rubbeerstamp honoring Tony Jannus U.S. Scott #C23-79a - unknown violet rubbeerstamp honoring Tony Jannus U.S. Scott #C23-79a - unknown violet rubbeerstamp honoring Tony Jannus

  166. U.S. Scott #C23-80 - St. Paul, MN National Air Mail Week -- XIII:98
  167. U.S. Scott #C23-81 - William T. Raley (W.T.) -- XIII:98
  168. U.S. Scott #C23-81b - William T. Raley (W.T.) -- XIII:98 --- (eBay)
    U.S. Scott #C23-81b - William T. Raley (W.T.)
  169. U.S. Scott #C23-82 - unknown -- XIII:98
  170. U.S. Scott #C23-83 - unknown -- XIII:98 --- (eBay)
    U.S. Scott #C23-83 - unknown U.S. Scott #C23-83 - unknown

  171.       The above 83 Planty Catalog Numbers are those #C23 cachets known at the time the 1984 Planty 1st edition was published. The following is all the newly reported Planty Catalog Numbers which only appear in the 2001 Planty 2nd edition.

  172. U.S. Scott #C23-84 - unknown -- XIII:98-99
  173. U.S. Scott #C23-85 - Ralph Dyer -- XIII:99
  174. U.S. Scott #C23-86 - Marion Fulton (Breswick Cover Service) -- XIII:99 --- (eBay)
    U.S. Scott #C23-86 - Marion Fulton (Breswick Cover Service) U.S. Scott #C23-86 - Marion Fulton (Breswick Cover Service)
  175. U.S. Scott #C23-87 - unknown -- XIII:99
  176. U.S. Scott #C23-88 - William J. Kotab -- XIII:99
  177. U.S. Scott #C23-89 - W.S. Beardsley (Waiten) -- XIII:99 -- (eBay)
    U.S. Scott #C23-89 - W.S. Beardsley (Waiten) U.S. Scott #C23-89 - W.S. Beardsley (Waiten)

  178. U.S. Scott #C23-90 - unknown -- XIII:99 --- (eBay)
    U.S. Scott #C23-90 - unknown U.S. Scott #C23-90 - unknown U.S. Scott #C23-90 - unknown
  179. U.S. Scott #C23-91 - unknown -- XIII:99
  180. U.S. Scott #C23-92 - unknown -- XIII:99-100
  181. U.S. Scott #C23-93 - unknown -- XIII:100
  182. U.S. Scott #C23-94 - Corn Cut -- XIII:100
  183. U.S. Scott #C23-95 - J. Neal Griffith -- XIII:100
  184. U.S. Scott #C23-96 - 1st Leatherstocking Stamp Club (Alfred R. Cobbett) -- XIII:100
  185. U.S. Scott #C23-96-INVALID - forged cachet --- (eBay)
    U.S. Scott #C23-96-INVALID - forged cachet
  186. U.S. Scott #C23-97 - unknown -- XIII:100
  187. U.S. Scott #C23-98 - Charles Egli -- XIII:100
  188. U.S. Scott #C23-99 - unknown -- XIII:100

  189. U.S. Scott #C23-100 - Aurora, IL Chamber of Commerce -- XIII:101
  190. U.S. Scott #C23-101 - F.R. Rice (Frederick Roger) -- XIII:101
  191. U.S. Scott #C23-101a - F.R. Rice (Frederick Roger) -- XIII:101
  192. U.S. Scott #C23-101b - F.R. Rice (Frederick Roger) -- XIII:101
  193. U.S. Scott #C23-102 - Michael Sanders, RCD #156 -- XIII:101 --- (eBay)
    U.S. Scott #C23-102 - Michael Sanders
  194. U.S. Scott #C23-103 - unknown -- XIII:101 --- (eBay ***)
    U.S. Scott #C23-103 - unknown
  195. U.S. Scott #C23-104 - unknown -- XIII:101
  196. U.S. Scott #C23-105 - 1st D.L. Suit -- XIII:102
  197. U.S. Scott #C23-106 - unknown -- XIII:102
  198. U.S. Scott #C23-107 - unknown -- XIII:102 --- (eBay ***)
    U.S. Scott #C23-107 - unknown
  199. U.S. Scott #C23-108 - unknown -- XIII:102
  200. U.S. Scott #C23-109 - unknown -- XIII:102

  201. U.S. Scott #C23-110 - J.J. Martin (Newport, RI Postmaster 19??-19??) -- XIII:102
  202. U.S. Scott #C23-111 - Berkshire, MA Post Office -- XIII:102
  203. U.S. Scott #C23-112 - Merchants Assoc. of Bronxville -- XIII:102-103
  204. U.S. Scott #C23-113 - New York Post Office -- XIII:103
  205. U.S. Scott #C23-114 - Nazareth, PA Chamber of Commerce -- XIII:103 --- (eBay)
    U.S. Scott #C23-114 - Nazareth, PA Chamber of Commerce
  206. U.S. Scott #C23-115 - 1st The Gem City Press -- XIII:103
  207. U.S. Scott #C23-116 - Dr. Harry C. Ioor, RCD #107 -- XIII:103 --- (eBay)
    U.S. Scott #C23-116 - Dr. Harry C. Ioor
  208. U.S. Scott #C23-117 - Dr. Harry C. Ioor, RCD #107 -- XIII:103
  209. U.S. Scott #C23-118 - Dr. Harry C. Ioor, RCD #107 -- XIII:103
  210. U.S. Scott #C23-119 - unknown -- XIII:103-104

  211. U.S. Scott #C23-120 - Linprint -- XIII:104 --- (eBay)
    U.S. Scott #C23-120 - Linprint
  212. U.S. Scott #C23-120a - Linprint -- XIII:104
  213. U.S. Scott #C23-121 - unknown -- XIII:104 --- (eBay) / (eBay ***)
    U.S. Scott #C23-121 - unknown U.S. Scott #C23-121 - unknown
  214. U.S. Scott #C23-122 - unknown -- XIII:104
  215. U.S. Scott #C23-123 - unknown -- XIII:104
  216. U.S. Scott #C23-124 - American Airlines -- XIII:104-105
  217. U.S. Scott #C23-124a - American Airlines -- XIII:104-105
  218. U.S. Scott #C23-124b - American Airlines -- XIII:104-105 --- (DLD)
    U.S. Scott #C23 -- American Airlines U.S. Scott #C23 -- American Airlines
  219. U.S. Scott #C23-125 - TWA (Trans World Airlines) -- XIII:105
  220. U.S. Scott #C23-125a - Inglewood Stamp & Cover Club -- XIII:105
  221. U.S. Scott #C23-126 - TWA (Trans World Airlines) -- XIII:105
  222. U.S. Scott #C23-127 - Gladys S. Adler, ACE #165 -- XIII:105-106
  223. U.S. Scott #C23-127a - Gladys S. Adler, ACE #165 -- XIII:105-106
  224. U.S. Scott #C23-127b - Gladys S. Adler, ACE #165 -- XIII:105-106
  225. U.S. Scott #C23-128 - 1st Dennis E. Barkley, Jr. -- XIII:106
  226. U.S. Scott #C23-128a - 1st Dennis E. Barkley, Jr. -- XIII:106
  227. U.S. Scott #C23-129 - Ralph Curran -- XIII:106 --- (eBay)
    U.S. Scott #C23-129 - Ralph Curran
  228. U.S. Scott #C23-129a - Ralph Curran -- XIII:106 --- (eBay)
    U.S. Scott #C23-129a - Ralph Curran

  229. U.S. Scott #C23-130 - Harold Van Sickle, ACE #148 -- XIII:106
  230. U.S. Scott #C23-131 - Mack Webb, ACE #59 -- XIII:106-107 --- (eBay)
    U.S. Scott #C23-131 - Mack Webb
  231. U.S. Scott #C23-131a - Mack Webb, ACE #59 -- XIII:106-107 --- (eBay)
    U.S. Scott #C23-131a - Mack Webb
  232. U.S. Scott #C23-132 - unknown -- XIII:107
  233. U.S. Scott #C23-133 - unknown -- XIII:107
  234. U.S. Scott #C23-134 - unknown -- XIII:107
  235. U.S. Scott #C23-135 - unknown -- XIII:107
  236. U.S. Scott #C23-136 - unknown -- XIII:107
  237. U.S. Scott #C23-137 - unknown -- XIII:107
  238. U.S. Scott #C23-138 - Washington Stamp Exchange (WSE) (Leo August, RCD #183) -- XIII:107-108
  239. U.S. Scott #C23-139 - C.S. Anderson (Charles Stephen) -- XIII:108

  240. U.S. Scott #C23-140 - unknown -- XIII:108 --- (eBay)
    U.S. Scott #C23-140 - unknown U.S. Scott #C23-140 - unknown
  241. U.S. Scott #C23-141 - HSR ? -- XIII:108 -- (eBay) / (eBay)
    U.S. Scott #C23-141 - HSR ? U.S. Scott #C23-141 - HSR ?
  242. U.S. Scott #C23-142 - possible Edward Kuntz -- XIII:108
  243. U.S. Scott #C23-143 - unknown -- XIII:108 --- (eBay)
    U.S. Scott #C23-143 - unknown
  244. U.S. Scott #C23-143a - unknown -- XIII:108
  245. U.S. Scott #C23-144 - unknown -- XIII:108-109 --- (eBay)
    U.S. Scott #C23-144 - unknown
  246. U.S. Scott #C23-145 - C.A. Gray -- XIII:109
  247. U.S. Scott #C23-146 - unknown -- XIII:109
  248. U.S. Scott #C23-147 - William S. Espenshade -- XIII:109 --- (eBay)
    U.S. Scott #C23-147 - William S. Espenshade U.S. Scott #C23-147 - William S. Espenshade
  249. U.S. Scott #C23-148 - unknown -- XIII:109
  250. U.S. Scott #C23-149 - unknown -- XIII:109

  251. U.S. Scott #C23-150 - unknown -- XIII:109
  252. U.S. Scott #C23-151 - unknown -- XIII:109
  253. U.S. Scott #C23-152 - unknown -- XIII:109-110
  254. U.S. Scott #C23-153 - Harry Tamer -- XIII:110 --- (eBay)
    U.S. Scott #C23-153 - Harry Tamer
  255. U.S. Scott #C23-154 - New York Post Office -- XIII:110
  256. U.S. Scott #C23-154a - New York Post Office -- XIII:110
  257. U.S. Scott #C23-154b - New York Post Office -- XIII:110
  258. U.S. Scott #C23-155 - unknown -- XIII:110
  259. U.S. Scott #C23-156 - Bosnak ? -- XIII:110-111
  260. U.S. Scott #C23-157 - unknown -- XIII:111
  261. U.S. Scott #C23-158 - unknown -- XIII:111
  262. U.S. Scott #C23-159 - unknown -- XIII:111

  263. U.S. Scott #C23-160 - unknown -- XIII:111 -- {A} / (eBay)
    U.S. Scott #C23-160 - unknown U.S. Scott #C23-160 - unknown
          Note the "A" to the left of the blue stripe. This could possibly be #C23-124c-NIP (American Airlines corner card), because their corner card might be underneath the Airmail sticker. I would have to remove the label and possibly damage the cover to verify this.
  264. U.S. Scott #C23-160a - unknown -- XIII:111
  265. U.S. Scott #C23-160b - unknown -- XIII:111
  266. U.S. Scott #C23-160c - unknown -- XIII:111
  267. U.S. Scott #C23-161 - unknown -- XIII:111-112
  268. U.S. Scott #C23-162 - Honolulu Advertiser -- XIII:112
  269. U.S. Scott #C23-163 - unknown -- XIII:112
  270. U.S. Scott #C23-164 - Eclipse Aviation -- XIII:112
  271. U.S. Scott #C23-165 - Bristol, RI Chamber of Commerce -- XIII:112
  272. U.S. Scott #C23-166 - unknown -- XIII:112
  273. U.S. Scott #C23-167 - Butte, MT Chamber of Commerce -- XIII:112-113
  274. U.S. Scott #C23-168 - New Haven, CT Chamber of Commerce -- XIII:113
  275. U.S. Scott #C23-169 - Cortland, NY Chamber of Commerce -- XIII:113

  276. U.S. Scott #C23-170 - Chicago, IL Chamber of Commerce -- XIII:113
  277. U.S. Scott #C23-171 - Cambridge, MD Chamber of Commerce -- XIII:113
  278. U.S. Scott #C23-172 - Waterbury, CT Chamber of Commerce -- XIII:113
  279. U.S. Scott #C23-173 - 1st Sarasota, FL Chamber of Commerce -- XIII:113
  280. U.S. Scott #C23-174 - 1st Birmingham Philatelic Society -- XIII:114
  281. U.S. Scott #C23-175 - 1st Dayton Rubber Mfg. Co. -- XIII:114
  282. U.S. Scott #C23-176 - 1st The Dayton Power & Light Company -- XIII:114

  283. (A) More Recent Add-Ons
  284. U.S. Scott #C23-A1 - John Anderson add-on -- XIII:114
  285. U.S. Scott #C23-A1a - John Anderson add-on -- XIII:114
  286. U.S. Scott #C23-A2 - J. Barbour add-on -- XIII:114-115
  287. U.S. Scott #C23-A2a - J. Barbour add-on -- XIII:114-115 --- (eBay)
    U.S. Scott #C23-A2a - J. Barbour
  288. U.S. Scott #C23-A2b - J. Barbour add-on -- XIII:114-115
  289. U.S. Scott #C23-A2c-NIP - J. Barbour add-on -- XIII:114-115 -- (eBay)
    U.S. Scott #C23-A2c - J. Barbour
  290. U.S. Scott #C23-A2d-NIP - J. Barbour add-on -- XIII:114-115 -- (eBay)
    U.S. Scott #C23-A2d - J. Barbour U.S. Scott #C23-A2c and #C23-A2d - J. Barbour
  291. U.S. Scott #C23-A3 - ? Dewitt -- XIII:115
  292. U.S. Scott #C23-A3a - ? Dewitt -- XIII:115
  293. U.S. Scott #C23-A3b - ? Dewitt -- XIII:115
  294. U.S. Scott #C23-A3c-NIP - ? Dewitt -- XIII:115 --- (eBay)
    U.S. Scott #C23-A3c-NIP - ? Dewitt
  295. U.S. Scott #C23-A4 - Jack Follows add-on -- XIII:115-116 --- (DLD)
    U.S. Scott #C23-A4 - Jack Follows add-on U.S. Scott #C23-A4 - Jack Follows add-on
  296. U.S. Scott #C23-A4a - Jack Follows add-on -- XIII:115-116
  297. U.S. Scott #C23-A4b - Jack Follows add-on -- XIII:115-116 --- (DLD)
    U.S. Scott #C23-A4b - Jack Follows add-on U.S. Scott #C23-A4b - Jack Follows add-on
  298. U.S. Scott #C23-A4c - Jack Follows add-on -- XIII:115-116 --- (DLD)
    U.S. Scott #C23-A4c - Jack Follows add-on U.S. Scott #C23-A4c - Jack Follows add-on
  299. U.S. Scott #C23-A4d - Jack Follows add-on -- XIII:115-116 --- (DLD)
    U.S. Scott #C23-A4d - Jack Follows add-on U.S. Scott #C23-A4d - Jack Follows add-on
  300. U.S. Scott #C23-A4e - Jack Follows add-on -- XIII:115-116 --- (DLD)
    U.S. Scott #C23-A4e - Jack Follows add-on U.S. Scott #C23-A4e - Jack Follows add-on
  301. U.S. Scott #C23-A4f - Jack Follows add-on -- XIII:115-116
  302. U.S. Scott #C23-A4g - Jack Follows add-on -- XIII:115-116
  303. U.S. Scott #C23-A4h-NIP - Jack Follows add-on -- XIII:115-116 -- (eBay)
    U.S. Scott #C23-A4h-NIP - Jack Follows
  304. U.S. Scott #C23-A4i-NIP - Jack Follows add-on -- XIII:115-116 -- (eBay)
    U.S. Scott #C23-A4i-NIP - Jack Follows
  305. U.S. Scott #C23-A4j-NIP - Jack Follows add-on -- XIII:115-116 --- (DLD)
    U.S. Scott #C23-A4j-NIP - Jack Follows add-on U.S. Scott #C23-A4j-NIP - Jack Follows add-on
  306. U.S. Scott #C23-A4k-NIP - Jack Follows add-on -- XIII:115-116 --- (DLD)
    U.S. Scott #C23-A4k-NIP - Jack Follows add-on U.S. Scott #C23-A4k-NIP - Jack Follows add-on
  307. U.S. Scott #C23-A4l-NIP - Jack Follows add-on -- XIII:115-116 --- (DLD)
    U.S. Scott #C23-A4l-NIP - Jack Follows add-on U.S. Scott #C23-A4l-NIP - Jack Follows add-on
  308. U.S. Scott #C23-A4m-NIP - Jack Follows add-on -- XIII:115-116 --- (DLD)
    U.S. Scott #C23-A4m-NIP - Jack Follows add-on U.S. Scott #C23-A4m-NIP - Jack Follows add-on
  309. U.S. Scott #C23-A4n-NIP - Jack Follows add-on -- XIII:115-116 --- (DLD)
    U.S. Scott #C23-A4n-NIP - Jack Follows add-on U.S. Scott #C23-A4n-NIP - Jack Follows add-on
  310. U.S. Scott #C23-A4o-NIP - Jack Follows add-on -- XIII:115-116 --- (eBay)
    U.S. Scott #C23-A4o-NIP - Jack Follows add-on
  311. U.S. Scott #C23-A4p-NIP - Jack Follows add-on -- XIII:115-116 --- (eBay)
    U.S. Scott #C23-A4p-NIP - Jack Follows add-on
  312. U.S. Scott #C23-A5 - Melissa Fox -- XIII:116 -- (DLD)
    U.S. Scott #C23-A5 - Melissa Fox U.S. Scott #C23-A5 - Melissa Fox
  313. U.S. Scott #C23-A5a - Melissa Fox -- XIII:117 -- (DLD)
    U.S. Scott #C23-A5a - Melissa Fox U.S. Scott #C23-A5a - Melissa Fox
  314. U.S. Scott #C23-A5b - Melissa Fox add-on -- XIII:117 -- (DLD)
    U.S. Scott #C23-A5b - Melissa Fox U.S. Scott #C23-A5b - Melissa Fox
  315. U.S. Scott #C23-A5c-NIP - Melissa Fox add-on with #C23-125a on the back -- XIII:117(NIP) -- (DLD)
    U.S. Scott #C23-A5c-NIP - Melissa Fox U.S. Scott #C23-A5c-NIP - Melissa Fox
  316. U.S. Scott #C23-A5d-NIP - Melissa Fox add-on -- XIII:117(NIP) -- (DLD)
    U.S. Scott #C23-A5d-NIP - Melissa Fox U.S. Scott #C23-A5d-NIP - Melissa Fox
  317. U.S. Scott #C23-A5e-NIP - Melissa Fox add-on -- XIII:117(NIP) -- (DLD)
    U.S. Scott #C23-A5e-NIP - Melissa Fox U.S. Scott #C23-A5e-NIP - Melissa Fox
  318. U.S. Scott #C23-A6 - Kribbs Kover (Kenneth Kribbs) add-on -- XIII:117
  319. U.S. Scott #C23-A6a - Kribbs Kover (Kenneth Kribbs) add-on -- XIII:117
  320. U.S. Scott #C23-A6b - Kribbs Kover (Kenneth Kribbs) add-on -- XIII:117
  321. U.S. Scott #C23-A6c - Kribbs Kover (Kenneth Kribbs) add-on -- XIII:117
  322. U.S. Scott #C23-A7 - John Ike add-on -- XIII:117
  323. U.S. Scott #C23-A7a - John Ike add-on -- XIII:118
  324. U.S. Scott #C23-A8 - unknown add-on -- XIII:118
  325. U.S. Scott #C23-A9 - unknown add-on -- XIII:118 --- (eBay)
    #C23-A9a? I have not seen the cachet pictured in Planty so I don't know whether this is by the same Cachetmaker or not.
    U.S. Scott #C23-A9a - unknown add-on U.S. Scott #C23-A9a - unknown add-on

  326. (A-NIP) More Recent Add-Ons, all Not in Planty
  327. U.S. Scott #C23-A10-NIP - [reserved for the next add-on I find.]
          My mistake, I installed the wrong cover here. It has been moved to #CE2-A1-NIP .
  328. U.S. Scott #C23-A11-NIP - unknown add-on -- (eBay)
          Until such time as their Cachetmaker(s) has/have been identified, I am listing these similar eagle hand-painted add-ons under one number.
          #C23-A11-NIP -- #C23-A11b-NIP -- #C23-A11c-NIP -- #C23-A11d-NIP
    U.S. Scott #C23-A11-NIP - unknown add-on U.S. Scott #C23-A11b-NIP - unknown add-on U.S. Scott #C23-A11c-NIP - unknown add-on U.S. Scott #C23-A11d-NIP - unknown add-on
  329. U.S. Scott #C23-A12-NIP - unknown add-on -- (eBay)
    U.S. Scott #C23-A12-NIP - unknown add-on
  330. U.S. Scott #C23-A13-NIP -- unknown --- (eBay)
    U.S. Scott #C23-A13-NIP -- unknown
  331. U.S. Scott #C23-A13a-NIP -- unknown --- (eBay)
    U.S. Scott #C23-A13a-NIP -- unknown
  332. U.S. Scott #C23-A13b1-NIP -- unknown --- (eBay)
    U.S. Scott #C23-A13b1-NIP -- unknown
  333. U.S. Scott #C23-A13b2-NIP -- unknown --- (eBay)
    U.S. Scott #C23-A13b2-NIP -- unknown
  334. U.S. Scott #C23-A13c-NIP -- unknown --- (eBay)
    U.S. Scott #C23-A13c-NIP -- unknown
  335. U.S. Scott #C23-A14-NIP -- unknown --- (eBay)
    U.S. Scott #C23-A14-NIP -- unknown
  336. U.S. Scott #C23-A15-NIP - John W. Romppainen (ROMP) -- (eBay)
    U.S. Scott #C23-A15-NIP - John W. Romppainen (ROMP)

  337. (PC) Post Cards
  338. U.S. Scott #C23-PC1 - Dahlke Stationery & Mfg. Co. -- XIII:118
  339. U.S. Scott #C23-PC2 - unknown -- XIII:118

  340. (PC-NIP) Post Cards, all Not in Planty
  341. U.S. Scott #C23-PC3-NIP - unknown -- XIII:118
          View of the same Monument, but a different post card.
    U.S. Scott #C23-PC3-NIP - U.S. Scott #C23-PC3-NIP -
  342. U.S. Scott #C23-PC4-NIP - unknown --- (eBay)
    U.S. Scott #C23-PC4-NIP - U.S. Scott #C23-PC4-NIP -

  343. (GP) General Purpose
  344. U.S. Scott #C23-GP1 - unknown -- XIII:119
          #C23-GP1 -- with #C23-79 rubberstamp --- (DLD)
    U.S. Scott #C23-GP1 - unknown U.S. Scott #C23-GP1 - unknown
          #C23-GP1 -- without rubberstamp -- (eBay ***)
    U.S. Scott #C23-NIP5 - ? Kessler
          #C23-GP1a -- no coloring with #C23-79 rubberstamp --- (DLD)
    U.S. Scott #C23-GP1a - unknown U.S. Scott #C23-GP1a - unknown
          #C23-GP1b -- same colors as #C23-GP1 but the design was moved left cutting off the parts of the design to the left of her right elbow --- (DLD)
    U.S. Scott #C23-GP1b - unknown U.S. Scott #C23-GP1b - unknown
          #C23-GP1c -- same colors and design as #C23-GP1 except the background is brown instead of green --- (DLD)
    U.S. Scott #C23-GP1c - unknown U.S. Scott #C23-GP1c - unknown
          #C23-GP1d -- same colors and design as #C23-GP1c with an added airmail label --- (DLD)
    U.S. Scott #C23-GP1d - unknown U.S. Scott #C23-GP1d - unknown
          1940 Event, two years later, possibly the source of the above designs is by Nat Williams. It is not known whether Nat Williams created the above covers or not. This is #8 of 10 humorous designs he explained in the filler. --- (DLD)
    U.S. Scott # - Nat Williams U.S. Scott # - Nat Williams, filler side A U.S. Scott # - Nat Williams, filler side B
  345. U.S. Scott #C23-GP2 - F.E. Lerchenfeld -- XIII:119
  346. U.S. Scott #C23-GP3 - unknown -- XIII:119
  347. U.S. Scott #C23-GP4 - Pavois (Stebbin) (SM Co.) -- XIII:119-120
  348. U.S. Scott #C23-GP5 - Howard D. Egolf (Davis), RCD #131 -- XIII:120
  349. U.S. Scott #C23-GP6 - unknown -- XIII:120
  350. U.S. Scott #C23-GP7 - unknown -- XIII:120
  351. U.S. Scott #C23-GP8 - Michael Sanders, RCD #156 -- XIII:120
  352. U.S. Scott #C23-GP9 - E.C. Lawrence (was unknown) -- XIII:120
          identified at [#384, 55(5), 7-15-2010, p. 38-9]

  353. U.S. Scott #C23-GP10 - unknown -- XIII:121
  354. U.S. Scott #C23-GP11 - 1st James B. Gilroy -- XIII:121
  355. U.S. Scott #C23-GP12 - William J. Von Ohlen -- XIII:121 -- (eBay)
    U.S. Scott #C23-GP12 - William J. Von Ohlen
  356. U.S. Scott #C23-GP13 - Witts Market House (corner card) -- XIII:121
  357. U.S. Scott #C23-GP14 - unknown -- XIII:121
  358. U.S. Scott #C23-GP15 - possible Edward G. Hacker (was unknown) -- XIII:121 -- (eBay) / (eBay) / (DLD) / (DLD)
          See the   #CE1-3   copied here for comparison.
    U.S. Scott #C23-GP15 - possible Edward G. Hacker U.S. Scott #CE1-3 - Edward G. Hacker U.S. Scott #C23-GP15 - possible Edward G. Hacker U.S. Scott #CE1-3 - Edward G. Hacker
  359. U.S. Scott #C23-GP16 - unknown -- XIII:121
  360. U.S. Scott #C23-GP17 - unknown -- XIII:121
  361. U.S. Scott #C23-GP18 - unknown -- XIII:122
  362. U.S. Scott #C23-GP19 - unknown -- XIII:122

  363. U.S. Scott #C23-GP20 - unknown -- XIII:122
  364. U.S. Scott #C23-GP21 - Adam K. Bert -- XIII:122

  365. (GP-NIP) General Purpose, all Not in Planty
  366. U.S. Scott #C23-GP22-NIP - unknown -- (eBay)
    U.S. Scott #C23-GP22-NIP - unknown
  367. U.S. Scott #C23-GP23-NIP - unknown -- (eBay)
    U.S. Scott #C23-GP23-NIP - unknown
  368. U.S. Scott #C23-GP24-NIP - unknown -- (eBay)
    U.S. Scott #C23-GP24-NIP - unknown
  369. U.S. Scott #C23-GP25-NIP - unknown -- (eBay)
    U.S. Scott #C23-GP25-NIP - unknown
  370. U.S. Scott #C23-GP26-NIP - unknown
          Renumbered to C23-A11d-NIP
  371. U.S. Scott #C23-GP27-NIP - unknown -- (eBay ***)
    U.S. Scott #C23-GP27-NIP - unknown
  372. U.S. Scott #C23-GP28-NIP - unknown -- (eBay)
    U.S. Scott #C23-GP28-NIP - unknown
  373. U.S. Scott #C23-GP29-NIP - unknown -- (eBay)
    U.S. Scott #C23-GP29-NIP - unknown
  374. U.S. Scott #C23-GP30-NIP - unknown -- (eBay)
    U.S. Scott #C23-GP30a-NIP - unknown U.S. Scott #C23-GP30b-NIP - unknown (back)

  375. (FC-NIP) First Cachets, all Not in Planty
          FC#C23-A - FC#C23-C is listed and pictured on page ppp of First Cachets (2006), and page I-210-211 of First Cachets Revealed, Vol. 1 (2005) .

  376. U.S. Scott FC#C23-A - 1st Frederick L. Noll ***
  377. U.S. Scott FC#C23-B - 1st Frigidaire, Dayton, OH ***
  378. U.S. Scott FC#C23-C - 1st Howard Paper Company, Urbana, OH ***

  379. (CC-NIP) Corner Cards, all Not in Planty
  380. U.S. Scott #C23-CC1a-NIP - The Postmaster General, James A. Farley (corner card) -- (eBay)
    U.S. Scott #C23-CC1a-NIP - The Postmaster General U.S. Scott #C23-CC1a-NIP - The Postmaster General, James A. Farley letter
  381. U.S. Scott #C23-CC1b-NIP - The Postmaster General, James A. Farley (corner card) -- (eBay)
    U.S. Scott #C23-CC1b-NIP - The Postmaster General     envelope contents unknown
  382. U.S. Scott #C23-CC2-NIP - reserved for future reports of U.S. Senate corner cards
  383. U.S. Scott #C23-CC3-NIP - reserved for future reports of U.S. House corner cards
  384. U.S. Scott #C23-CC4-NIP - reserved for future reports of White House corner cards
  385. U.S. Scott #C23-CC5e-NIP - Hoffman & Mayer, Inc., New York, NY (corner card) -- (eBay)
    U.S. Scott #C23-CC5e-NIP - Hoffman & Mayer, Inc., New York, NY (corner card) U.S. Scott #C23-CC5e-NIP - Hoffman & Mayer, Inc., New York, NY (corner card) U.S. Scott #C23-CC5e-NIP - Hoffman & Mayer, Inc., New York, NY (corner card)
  386. U.S. Scott #C23-CC6-NIP - Columbia University, College of Pharmacy, New York City (corner card) -- (eBay)
    U.S. Scott #C23-CC6-NIP - Columbia University, College of Pharmacy, New York City (corner card)

  387. (NIP) Not in Planty
  388. U.S. Scott #C23-NIP1 - Henry M. Luethke, ACE #104 -- (eBay)
    U.S. Scott #C23-NIP1 - unknown
  389. U.S. Scott #C23-NIP2 - Carl M. Becken -- (eBay)
    U.S. Scott #C23-NIP2 - Carl M. Becken
  390. U.S. Scott #C23-NIP3 - Brian Ponika -- (eBay)
    U.S. Scott #C23-NIP3 - Brian Ponika
  391. U.S. Scott #C23-NIP4a - Walter F. Dancey (NOT Dancy) -- (eBay)
    U.S. Scott #C23-NIP4a - Walter F. Dancey
  392. U.S. Scott #C23-NIP4b - Walter F. Dancey (NOT Dancy) -- (eBay)
    U.S. Scott #C23-NIP4b - Walter F. Dancey
  393. U.S. Scott #C23-NIP5 - unknown, (probably NOT ? Kessler) -- (eBay ***)
          Moved to #C23-GP1 without rubberstamp
  394. U.S. Scott #C23-NIP6 - B.R. McIntyre (Bruce), ACE #88 or ACE #32 -- (eBay ***)
    U.S. Scott #C23-NIP6 - B.R. McIntyre (Bruce)
  395. U.S. Scott #C23-NIP7 - unknown -- (eBay ***)
    U.S. Scott #C23-NIP7 - unknown
  396. U.S. Scott #C23-NIP8 - unknown -- (eBay)
    U.S. Scott #C23-NIP8 - unknown
  397. U.S. Scott #C23-NIP9 - Kate Hayden -- (eBay)
    U.S. Scott #C23-NIP9 - Kate Hayden
  398. U.S. Scott #C23-NIP10 - unknown -- (eBay)
    U.S. Scott #C23-NIP10 - unknown
Previous: Planty #C21-22 Cachet List -- Next: Planty #C24 Cachet List -- All U.S. Scott # Cachet Lists
What's New on this page -- changes since 05-01-2022:
03-24-2024 -- Added #C23-34b
02-07-2023 -- Added #C23-A4o-NIP -- #C23-A4p-NIP
02-05-2023 -- Added #C23-A4n-NIP
06-30-2022 -- Added 16 scans: 26-1a, 26-3a, 26-4a, 26a-2a, 35a, 38a (St P.), 38a1, A13a, A13b1, A13b2, A13c, A15, GP30a, GP30b, NIP9, NIP10
URL: https://www.folklib.net/fdc/bibliog/planty-c23.shtml
Return to the top of the page Menu

Page created by Douglas H. Henkle (Contact): henkle@pobox.com